Thursday, October 14, 2010

To say that hip hop encourages or facilitates the violent behavior to which it pertains feels like an easy way out. There had to have been "urban atrocities" to begin with in order to inspire this reactionary art—thus, the anger in a lot of rap and the themes of revenge and police harassment, as well as murder, drive-bys and gang violence. People rapped about issues they felt were not being discussed in other cultural forms; they needed an outlet for urban frustration that was not being expressed. However, yes, by commodifying these events by putting them into a marketable cultural form, it does desensitize people to the idea of violence and "urban atrocities," or at least to their existence in popular culture. I mean, who is going to want to listen to a song — "oh, I'm Black but I feel White people and the police respect me, my life's pretty good." Hip hop by nature comes out of angst and anger, and therefore makes those emotions seem like the norm for those listening, yet while it presents these moods as acceptable, and violence as a frequent occurrence, placing violence within that angry context still makes it seem like a bad thing — if you commit a drive-by shooting, you'll only be unhappy.

1 comment:

  1. I think people who do drive by shootings are probably pretty happy with what they are doing; therein lies the problem, right? It is an easy way out to say art created problems, or even that problems create art; it is a dialogic process and highly contextual. I'd say the biggest problem is that hip-hop and hip-hop cinema is a hugely profitable genre, but none of it has led to transformation with the issues it raises. When I went to a Public Enemy concert back in the early 90s and they came out with KKK outfits on and did some diatribe about racism, the audience just laughed. When I saw Ice T at Lalapalooza and the mosh pit started, none seemed affected by his misogynistic songs, or songs about the police; they were bopping their heads and beating each other in mosh pit. I always have students who write on films like Juice, and love that film, and often those are the same that hold huge stereotypes of African Americans or about racial issues. This conundrum will make this week's question ever the more important. Maybe the issue is that popular culture is not the site of transformation, or maybe the issue is we have to become ever more critical about consuming it. As always, thanks for your high level and sophisticated engagement; your posts are always a pleasure to read and ones that I look forward to.

    Cheers,

    ReplyDelete